Austin Hall

HOME
ORDER
ISSUES
MANUSCRIPTS
COPYRIGHT
MEMBERSHIP
ABOUT HLR
MASTHEAD
THE BLUEBOOK

Harvard Law Review
Gannett House
1511 Massachusetts Ave
Cambridge, MA 02138

Editorial Office:
617-495-7889
617-496-5053 (fax)

Business Office:
617-495-4650
617-495-2748 (fax)



About the Forum       Submissions       All Responses

Modeling Agency/Court Interaction
by Emerson Tiller & Frank B. Cross    [ Full Text ]
121 Harv. L. Rev. F. 13 (2007)
Responding to Matthew C. Stephenson, The Strategic Substitution Effect: Textual Plausibility, Procedural Formality, and Judicial Review of Agency Statutory Interpretations, 120 Harv. L. Rev. 528 (2006)

The positive political theory of legal rules, such as those providing for judicial review, has received far too little attention. Professor Matthew Stephenson’s analysis of his strategic substitution effect is therefore a significant development. In this Response, we acknowledge that he has made some material and valuable advances in the way we should think about the positive interaction of agencies and courts. However, his model has important limitations and in practice it may describe less than we would like. Nonetheless, the Article’s value can be found in its original conceptual ideas, which may be expanded upon to develop a more valuable theory of the effect of legal rules in administrative law. [ More ]

Suggested citation: Emerson Tiller & Frank B. Cross, Modeling Agency/Court Interaction, 121 Harv. L. Rev. F. 13 (2007), http://www.harvardlawreview.org/forum/issues/120/dec06/tiller_cross.pdf


To view Harvard Law Review PDFs online you will need Adobe Acrobat Reader.
Download it here for free!


© 2007 The Harvard Law Review Association
webmaster@harvardlawreview.org